While there are plenty of great rivalries in baseball, the Red Sox vs Yankees rivalry isn’t just on the field, it’s a battle to win the battle of legacies, the battle of legends and the battle of the fans. While every matchup is filled with drama, it’s the player stats that really make the real story. Every swing, pitch and game changing moment is captured on these numbers, from breakout rookies to veteran sluggers.
Each stat is another log thrown on the historic fire; whether it’s a clutch home run or a pitching duel that quiets the crowd, it is all just feeding the hype. In this breakdown, we’ll dig deep into the most recent Red Sox vs Yankees match player stats in order to find out who actually did make the difference and how the rivalry continues to progress through performance.
Overview of the Red Sox vs Yankees Rivalry
A century of baseball brilliance and bitter animosity is the saga of the Red Sox–Yankees rivalry. The one that started in 1919 when Boston sold Babe Ruth to New York, igniting the “Curse of the Bambino,” the 86 year title drought for the Red Sox.
Indeed, the Yankees capitalized, picking up 27 World Series titles over Boston, who didn’t get to taste champagne until their 2004 ALCS comeback, becoming the first MLB team to come back from 0–3 to win a series and the World Series.
The Yankees edged out the regular season series 1,257–1,049–14 but split the postseason series 12–12. Among its historic moments and its passionate fanbases, this rivalry is one of the most intense in sports.
Key Players to Watch in the Red Sox vs Yankees Match
With a number of standout players who will go on to make big impacts, we’re in for another blockbuster chapter of the Red Sox–Yankees rivalry.
Yankees:
Aaron Judge: Continuing his MVP caliber performance, Aaron Judge is leading the league in home runs with 16 this season. He’s a constant threat because of his ability to change the game’s momentum.
Cody Bellinger: Bellinger was slow out of the gate, but has found his rhythm, sporting a 1.053 OPS in May. The resurgence gives the Yankees a little more depth in their lineup.
Max Fried: Acquired as pitching staff depth, Fried has led MLB with a 1.29 ERA to give the Yankees a menacing presence on the mound.
Red Sox:
Garrett Crochet: Boston’s ace in the making, Garrett Crochet has posted a 2.00 ERA over 10 starts with improved command and a variety of pitches.
Jarren Duran: Dynamic outfielder Jarren Duran continues to set the tone at the top of Boston’s offense and is riding off the back of his 2024 All Star MVP.
Alex Bregman: Bregman has been a steady offensive producer since joining the Red Sox and hit home run No. 200 in his career last week.
With these key players all out on the field, their performances will no doubt affect the result of the latest installment of this storied rivalry.
Analyzing Batting Stats: Red Sox vs Yankees
2025 Red Sox Yankees rivalry as hot as ever: Both teams have potent offenses.
New York Yankees
MLB’s best lineup belongs to the Yankees, who lead the way with 79 home runs and are third with a .261 batting average. But Aaron Judge is having an MVP season, hitting .401 with 15 home runs and 41 RBIs. And Paul Goldschmidt complements him at .339, with 5 home runs and 25 RBIs. But Cody Bellinger has rebounded impressively, his average at .340 during an 11 game hitting streak. 12 home runs and a .267 average give Trent Grisham depth.
Boston Red Sox
The Red Sox remain a strong offensive team, scoring .253 as a team and 62 home runs. Rafael Devers hits .286 with 10 home runs and Alex Bregman hits .304 with 11. 11 home runs and a .264 average power things up for Wilyer Abreu.
Though the Yankees’ lineup is more explosive right now, a balanced offense has kept the Red Sox competitive. These batting stats will be key as the season moves along and as always with the storied rivalry, you can be sure it won’t be decided by batting records.
Breaking Down Pitching Stats for the Red Sox vs Yankees Clash
Red Sox and Yankees rivalry continues in 2025 and both the teams feature solid pitching staffs that could prove to be the difference in this classic battle.
New York Yankees.
Max Fried leads the league with a 1.29 ERA over 62.2 innings, 60 strikeouts and a 6–0 record and anchors the rotation for the Yankees. He’s backed by Carlos Rodón with a 3.17 ERA and 72 strikeouts in 59.2 innings. Rookie Will Warren has been a workhorse, throwing a career high 10 strikeouts over 5.2 innings without allowing a run in a recent start and has now struck out 34 in May. Depth and late inning stability come from the bullpen which includes Mark Leiter Jr. (2.94 ERA) and Devin Williams (4 saves).
Boston Red Sox
Red Sox Garrett Crochet, with 2.00 ERA and 73 strikeouts in 63 innings, is an early Cy Young contender leading the Red Sox rotation. Aroldis Chapman, effective late out of the bullpen, has a 1.89 ERA and 8 saves. A 3.00 ERA over 21 innings is lent some support by Greg Weissert. But the Red Sox pitching staff has given up a .256 batting average to opponents, 23rd in MLB.
With the Red Sox and Yankees set to square off during the season’s most heated rivalry matchup, the effectiveness of their pitching staffs will be key.
Historical Player Performance in Red Sox vs Yankees Matches
The natural rivalry between the Red Sox and Yankees has been defined or at least shaped, by legendary performances that have impacted baseball history in ways that will never be forgotten.
Babe Ruth: After being sold to the Yankees in 1919, Ruth became a powerhouse, leading New York to several championships and forever casting the ‘Curse of the Bambino’ over Boston.
Ted Williams vs. Joe DiMaggio (1941): Ted Williams vs. Joe DiMaggio. Williams hit .406, DiMaggio was hitting in 56 games in a row to win MVP; it was a great year to be a player.
Manny Ramirez: In 112 games against the Yankees, Manny Ramirez hit .340 with 33 home runs, 90 RBIs and delivered in high pressure situations.
David Ortiz: Ortiz was the hero in the 2004 ALCS, including clutch hits in Games 4 and 5, as the Red Sox erased a 0–3 deficit against the Yankees to capture their first pennant in 86 years.
Aaron Boone: His walk-off home run in Game 7 of the 2003 ALCS was one of the most iconic moments in the rivalry, says Aaron Boone.
They weren’t just games defining performances, but they helped solidify this long lasting rivalry in baseball as one of the best.
Final Word
A Red Sox vs Yankees game is never just another game, it’s a statistical battle ground where legacies are made. Every matchup in this historical series gives more fuel to Aaron Judge’s slugging dominance, Garrett Crochet’s rising ace status and more. These player stats don’t just tell a story, they define the outcome, whether you’re a fan tracking batting averages or ERA trends. Every pitch, swing and stat in this rivalry still means more than ever, so stay tuned.
